Voters Turn Against Democrats in Ohio Swing District

Thursday, October 14, 2010 - 08:28 AM

Alice Prestier used to worked at Hoover's Vacuums, which closed after she worked there three decades. Now she wonder's: where's the change? (Andrea Bernstein)

(Canton, Ohio) Alice Prestier has lived in these parts all her life, raising her children and grandchildren here. For 30 years, she worked for Hoover's vacuum company. “If they would have told me that Hoover's was going to go out of business I would have never believed it.  Not a company that big. You got too many big companies that just left Canton, Ohio. And this was a nice booming town.”

She ticks off the employers that have left Canton in recent years. “Ford Company. Bliss Company. Hercules. Canton Stamping. Canton Provisions. There was a lot of companies around here. We lost them all. Everything’s gone.” 

There are some gorgeous buildings in downtown Canton. The Canton tower has green-veined black marble deco accents, kind of like a mini-Rockefeller Center, but it’s mostly boarded up now. Once, this town was going to be someplace.  Now, like so many rust belt towns, it’s struggling to figure out what comes next. Large buildings that draw people together in a central downtown are out. Strip malls are in.

“People are just desperate. They want to eat. They want to feed their children. They want to take care of their families. It’s gotten to that place,” Prestier told me, recounting a story she’d just heard on the radio warning people to lock their cars when they bought groceries because people were roving the parking lots, looking for ways to feed their families. We were standing right then in the Walmart SuperCenter lot, where people were doing that: Buying food. Locking their cars. 

Prestier isn’t sure who she’s voting for this year, but she’s skeptical of everyone in power. “Where’s the change?” she asked me, a question that echoed all through this town, nestled about where cornfields begin to meet the rolling foothills of the Appalachian mountains.  

In 2008, this county voted narrowly for Obama. In 2000, it voted even more narrowly for Bush. But Hillary Clinton won it hands down in the March 2008 presidential primary. More than one person told me their vote for Hillary Clinton was the last one they cast. 

In election after election, this area goes red, then blue, the red. In 2008, after decades of sending moderate Republican Ralph Regula to Congress, Regula retired, and Democrat John Boccieri, a former state legislator and Air Force major, won Ohio’s Sixteenth Congressional district. Boccieri voted for what opponents spittingly call “cap and trade,” and the stimulus bill, and the health care bill. 

Rep. John Boccieri

Rep. John Boccieri won office in 2008 after 36 years of Republican reign in the 16th CD. He "makes no bones" about his votes for health care and the stimulus.

“I have made no bones about the votes I’ve taken. I stand behind them. I would do them again, quite frankly,” Boccieri told me after a small lunchtime get-out-the-vote rally in downtown Canton. “Our country needs to be put on a path towards success and prosperity and we need to invest in our greatest asset, our people, which is what these votes have done.”

How’s that playing in this district?

“People are uneasy, they’re uncertain about the economic mess we just came through, and they’re being made more anxious quite frankly, by the special interest groups that are trying to confuse people, disorient them. That’s been the most tragic part of this.”

Every commercial break, it seems, three ads run accusing some Democrat of raising taxes, killing jobs—one even shows the stripes peeling off the American flag. With ominous pictures and scary music, the ads—run not only by the parties but by groups like the Chamber of Commerce and the NRA—all but charge Democrats with kidnapping your first born child. 

At the rally, Democratic candidate for Lt. Governor Yvette McGee Brown, forcefully made the argument that the Democrats were doing all they can—that Democrats are not responsible for this mess. Her speech was urgent, fiery.

Yvette McGee Brown

Lt. Governor candidate Yvette McGee Brown says "it's not the democrats" who created the financial mess.

“I need you to go out and say to the voters, look. I get that you’re angry. I understand this economy has been hard on people! But you got to remember who brought this economy down: it was not the Democrats!”


Out in the plaza on a sunny October day, a group of women eating their lunch just let the words bounce off them. Most of them had voted already. Were they persuaded by what they heard? A chorus of “no’s.” 

“I’m making a full change this year,” a banker called Jane told me. Everyone who’s in goes out? “Pretty much.”

A bit later that day, I was out in the Fisher Foods parking lot.  

Linda Rich, who works at Timkins, one of Canton’s last big employers, voted for Obama in 2008. What does she thing of the job he’s done? “I think he could do better.” In what area?  “All... I’m sort of wishing I wouldn’t have voted for him now.”

Part of the problem for the Democrats is that their signature measure, health care, is like “rocket science,” as laborer Tina Sherman told me. “I just don’t understand it.” Those who like the idea of health care form told me “it didn’t go far enough.” The stimulus hasn’t enough jobs to make a difference—even though some area employers are benefitting from the clean energy provisions of the bill, and everyone got a tax cut.  No one notices that. One Democrat railed on Obama for taking too many “out-of-town trips.” 

In a ninety minute debate between Boccieri and the Libertarian candidate, Jim Blevins, (the Republican, Jim Renacci, sat this one out), Obama’s name was first mentioned at minute 78. Boccieri invoked Ralph Regula more times than I can count on both hands.

That’s working to the advantage of Republican Jim Renacci, the former Wadsworth Mayor and a businessman running against Boccieri. If he’s elected—and the political projection services are giving him the edge—how would he govern in an environment where voters have been subjected to all kinds of negativity on TV? Where the Republicans have been accused of merely obstructing the Democrats, while not putting forward an agenda of their own?

Bud Spicer and Claude Wright, both retired truckers.

Retired truckers Bud Spicer (left) and Claude Wright "aren't ashamed" of their Obama votes.

“A no vote is not an obstructionary vote,” Renacci told me at his office in a long low building near a strip mall. “It’s a vote for the American people right now. So when people are voting no, they’re not comfortable, and the American people aren’t comfortable with our direction."

Renacci wants to repeal the health care bill, and reduce business regulation.  He wants to make the Bush tax cuts permanent. Stimulus, to him, has been a failure, and though he believes in infrastructure spending, he doesn’t think there’s extra money lying around for an extra spending in that area that right now.   

Of course, there are Obama partisans here. “I ain’t ashamed to say I voted for him,” 89-year old retired trucker Bud Spicer said of Obama at the L.A. City Diner. “I’d vote for him again. I mean the world, right now, is in bad shape.” On the words "bad shape," another trucker, Claude Wright, chimed in. They both said “bad shape,” at the same time. “You can’t overcome it in one night, three nights,” Spicer added. “It’s going to take years to get it back where it was. That’s how I got it figured out.  And I’ve seen a lot of changes in my day. I’ve seen black people have to get off the bus—they weren’t allowed to ride the bus, they had to step off the sidewalk for you. I like the changes.”

Listen to Andrea's interview with Rep. John Boccieri:

Listen to Andrea's interview with Republican Jim Renacci:


More in:

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.