In-State Tuition for Undocumented Immigrants

Monday, November 26, 2012

Five months ago, President Obama launched the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, which enables people who immigrated illegally to the United States as children to defer removal from the country for two years.

And last week, Governor Deval Patrick of Massachusetts took things to the next level by issuing a directive to the state’s Board of Higher Education directing all state universities and colleges to charge undocumented students in-state tuition — just as they would charge in-state tuition to any other Massachusetts resident.

Is the directive fair? Or going too far?

Sarah Birnbaum is the political and statehouse reporter for WGBH. She’s been tracking local reaction to the directive and looking at how other states have — and haven’t — taken similar steps.

"Governor Patrick has always been supportive of this issue," Birnbaum says. "But since 2005 or so it's sort of been a non-starter, and the legislature just lost steam." 

"President Obama's directive has given him an opportunity to go forward with it," she says.

"What we're seeing is that some states are becoming more accommodating towards undocumented immigrants and some are becoming less so," Birnbaum says. "And you really can't track which states are doing what. It doesn't really follow your expectations." She cites New York, California, and Texas as states where undocumented immigrants are already able to pay in-state tuition. There are other states where this is explicitly barred, including Georgia, Arizona, and Ohio. "It cuts across partisan lines, which is really interesting."

Whether these are the first signs of a comprehensive immigration


reform remains to be seen, but Governor Patrick's actions will certainly make a difference in Massachusetts.


Sarah Birnbaum

Produced by:

Kristen Meinzer

Comments [3]

Linda Garfinkel from North Jersey

I am a Youth Services Librarian working in a public library. Like many of your listeners I grew up loving to read fiction. But there are many kids who never get turned onto reading because fiction does not interest them. Hopefully Common Core can help address this problem.

Nov. 28 2012 09:40 AM
CK from Westchester

Cady: You noted that the term "illegal immigrant" should not be used. Why not? They are not in fact, here legally. I'm not sure I'm against or in favor of in-state tuition for these students. Who is going to foot the bill? Does this then assume they are favored for entry over others who have earned their place on a campus?

Nov. 26 2012 03:25 PM
Cady Landa from Waltham, MA

Unfortunately, Sarah Birnbaum misunderstands what happened in MA around in-state tuition for people receiving a deferment under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA). According to state regulations that existed prior to DACA anyone who has received deferred action and has a work permit from the federal government receives in-state tuition. Thus,in-state tuition for individuals who receive the deferment and work permit from the federal government is NOT a change in state policy. Rather, it is the legal extension in MA of the change in federal policy. Please do not use the term "illegal immigrant." It is not a technically correct term and it has very unfortunate and negative connotations.

Nov. 26 2012 11:33 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.