I root for a Subway Series World Series every year. Why? Because I genuinely love both the Yankees and the Mets. Let me tell you why i want a baseball championship where all you have to do is go from the 7 train in Queens to the 4/5 in Manhattan to the Bronx.
In the first game of this past weekend's Subway Series, with all games being held in the Metropolitan's new stadium (which should be called Jackie Robinson Stadium instead CitiField), the Mets committed 3 unforced errors in the 2nd inning in a display of tremendously bad baseball. The Metropolitans, if you recall from history, are the step-franchise of the once great Brooklyn Dodgers and the New York Giants. Once NYC boasted the most MLB franchises of any city. This was the Capital of Baseball. For long- forgotten political and economic reasons the Giants and the Dodgers skipped town and left the city with its anchor iconic team, the NY Yankees. It was a stroke of genius to create another team, give them a Queens stadium, and combine the colors of the Dodgers and the Giants. The Brooklyn Bumbs live on in the 2009 Mets.... (continue reading)
My understanding of baseball reaches back to 1986. I lived on St. Johns between Washington and Underhill, in Brooklyn – not far from the old Dodgers’ Ebbets Field. That summer, bullets flew around NYC, a town awash in cocaine and crack money. Even my favorite players like Darryl Strawberry and Doc Gooden were playing on the party side of the fence. That 1986 team knew how to win and how to celebrate. They went on to win the World Series. Because it was such a dangerous town in that era, my brother, sister, and I were not allowed to go anywhere. We stayed in the house all summer watching soap operas and baseball games. And baseball became a soap opera as the Mets were on a historic run. Strawberry and “Doc” Gooden were my favorite players. I wanted that golf-drive uppercut swing like Strawberry and I wanted the lights-out arm of "Dr. K" Gooden. Even though their off-field exploits would become more famous than their play on the field, in 1986, to a nine-year-old, they were pure and could do no wrong.
Now, my Yankees. I love them. The Mets are inconsistent, the Knicks are heartbreakers, the Rangers and Islanders are a mess, and the Jets… don't get me started. The Giants make us proud, but it's the Yankees, with their 26 world championships – the most in any sport in the world – that represent NYC better than anything else. We like winners. I even rooted for Dave Winfield and Don Mattingly when they struggled for the Yankees through the lean years of the 1980’s.
How can I love both NY baseball teams? Because they're interconnected. Strawberry played for all four current or former New York teams: the New York Yankees, the New York Mets, the Los Angeles Dodgers, and the San Francisco Giants. He's the only player to spend his entire career playing for these teams. And Strawberry and Gooden are the only players to win a World Series championship with both of New York's current teams. Darryl and Doc may have had their problems, but they were winners and life is not about how you manage when things are good, but how you bounce back. They bounced back; they brought honor back to the Bronx! So there you have it. I am 32-years-old, but my inner nine-year-old is still rooting for both teams, no matter what old-timers, Queens’s residents, Yankee-haters, Bronx diehards or anybody else says. I was born here and I can root for both teams. So I want to see a Subway Series every year for the Fall Classic. (What did I do in 2000 when they met in the series? Ha! You have to ask. I defaulted and rooted for the Mets: I figure the Yanks have plenty, why not let the feisty rebels take one from the Evil Empire.)
Cheers to Mariano Rivera for recording his 500th save in last night’s game. The Yankees took all three at Jackie Robinson Stadium. I refuse to call it CitiField. Not just because I hate the name, but because since Citibank is more or less owned by the U.S. government, I figure the government can rename the stadium. What would be more perfect than naming the stadium for the man who broke baseball's color barrier? Don't you agree? Let me know. And tell me what team you rooted for as a child. Have you stuck with them or did they break your heart too many times?
Comments [6]
aaaaah, mr. Dumi... i actually do NOT recall hating the "stankees" i actually had a feeling of feeling sorry for Mattingly and Winfield because they were such good guys and loved it when Winfield got his ring - sadly, Mattingly left the Yanks a year to soon to get his... As a fan of baseball in general i feel that teams win based on pouring pure love into their teams and literally caring less about those "other" teams. Case in point: for most of the Yankees existence they acted as those though they were the only team in the planet. The Red Sox were an annoying gnat that flew in their face and they vanquished - squished. Now, Yankee fans are so obsessed with their hate of the Sox that it has blinded their love. the Yankees suck, the Red Sox are winning and leading... and the balance is off...
(cont) I know many people who "like" both teams, but they are usually not fans, for what can they be wildly invested in? baseball itself? maybe, but both NY teams, unacceptable. Your narrative of love and infatuation with Doc, Straw, Mookie et al is one that I share, but I can remember in those days talking trash to the Stankees, because bragging rights are what fuel sports rivalries. How can you have bragging rights if you root for both? Whether it's within families, across boroughs, or across the nation, the point of teams and NY sports are bragging rights. You can be a fan of baseball, but you can't be a fan of both teams because you eliminate the greatest part of being a fan: bragging rights.
Nice piece, though I beg to disagree. You position is one of convenience and I'm here to remind you that sports are nothing more than civilized war. And in war the spoils go to the victors, in the case of Yankees-Mets is all about bragging rights.
Bragging rights aren't about interleague play, since interleague play didn't start to 97, nor the individual accomplishments of players, since we now live in an era where players bounce around more than spalding balls.Rather bragging rights are the possession of the fan, more accurately known as the fanatic. And the fanatic is governed by a degree of illogical loyalty, that is what makes she or he a fan. It's funny because most folks of my generation are the last of a dying breed, the folks who foolishly invest in a team based on players but hold onto that team through the rollercoaster years and thus fulfill the age old rite of fan-ticide.
As I lifelong Yankee fan I still hold to my roots, even now as I live in Red Sox nation. Although I didn't growing up, I now understand rooting for both teams throughout the year, but come October a choice has to be made!
Its interesting that your point of contact with the two teams is filtered through the fact that your favorite players (Doc & Straw) made significant contributions to a world series championship in each league.
For anybody else the lines are drawn quite distinctly. You cant say that they have been direct rivals because they play in different leagues. (until inter-league play began in 97) But you can (make them rivals) more importantly for the same reason a dichotomy was made in the first place. To see the best teams from the 2 differently styled leagues compete for the bragging rights and more importantly a world series.
I had no idea the Mets' full name was the Metropolitans. Educational!
Leave a Comment
Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more. Learn more.
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting. By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.