Economy, Politics
What would you tax to fix your state’s budget crisis?
By John Hockenberry, Adaora Udoji, Adnaan Wasey
May 12, 2008, 09:53 AM
At least 28 states and the District of Columbia are expected to face budget shortfalls next year. What would you tax to fix your state’s budget crisis? Gas guzzlers? Beer? MP3s? Porn?
Leave your comment by clicking "get in the mix", by emailing mytake@thetakeaway.org, or by calling our SpinVox line at 1-877-8-MY-TAKE. Tune in Monday morning to hear what others had to say.
Chart: State deficits, 2008-2009
#2 Posted by hjs, May 09, 05:40PM
tax sprawl.
small communities cost more per capita. if a community doesn't want to share services with their neighbors then they should pay additional for this luxury not ask for additional state aid. also new housing developments never pay for the long term cost of damage to the environment, water, wildlife. urban areas are more sustainable and should not be asked to subsidize the sprawl any more.
#3 Posted by carl, May 09, 07:21PM
Ignorance, Selfishness & Greed.
#4 Posted by Bryan Bowman, May 09, 09:00PM
I tried to have an open mind about your show. But now you and Jonathan Schwartz are the only reasons I ever avert my dial from WNYC. We do not need wannapundits at that hour. And those stupid electronic squawk noises are infantile. The overall sound of the show is listless and dark. I am quite sure the Takeaway will hinder and prolong fundraising. Please, don't imitate Hilary: just recognize it wasn't a needed idea to begin with and just give it up before WFUV, WKCR, CD's or silence become habits. Bring back the rightful program. Sincerely, Bryan Bowman
#5 Posted by Mark Jeffries, May 09, 09:11PM
Mr. Bowman:
What in the hell does your comment have to do with state budgets and taxes?
And aren't you alleged progressives supposed to be in favor of change?
#6 Posted by Richard, May 10, 12:06AM
The premise of your question is wrong. Why tax to balance a budget?
Cut spending and work on reducing the horrific waste Government creates. What ever happened to Government of the people, by the people, and for the people? Governments everywhere are distinct entities that behave in a manner that maximizes their own interests.
It's not necessary to tax always at the very top of the Laffer Curve. Or is it?
How about Government just cutting back, as everyone else must? Why is Government's answer to recession increasing taxes?
And if you think giving Government your money is a good idea, ask yourself where you get more for your money, with HUD, a Government Agency, or with Habitat for Humanity, a private organization that works for the same goals.
#7 Posted by B.P., May 11, 09:07AM
I think taxes for sale of guns, automobiles and liquor should be increased.
#8 Posted by Kevin P, May 11, 10:37PM
Working people don't "make" money, businesses do. Tax business, not work.
In my book, work includes grocery shopping. If I buy the kids a chocolate bar, I pay sales tax. If I buy shares in the chocolate company I don't!
End the tax "holidays" and subsidies to big business: level the playing fields, free the "free market."
Stop subsidizing mortgage payments for non-primary residences.
Discourage consumption: double or triple tax on petroleum and petroleum products.
#9 Posted by Daveed Kapoor, May 12, 05:12AM
I agree with TPS - tax sprawl.
One should pay an enormously high tax to develop rural land that has not been developed before.
#10 Posted by Vince Marino, May 12, 06:22AM
Ego
More on Economy
More on Politics
More by John Hockenberry
More by Adaora Udoji
- Guest Blogger David Wall Rice: White Morehouse valedictorian not "slumming it"
- Mornings need a make over. What would you change?
- Your photos: The cubicle turns 40
- Salmon fishers head to Alaska, where stocks are high
- The Takeaway for May 14, 2008
- The Takeaway for May 15, 2008
- Clay Shirky on cognitive surplus and online participatory culture
- The Web sites that command your time and contributions
- Making Iraq accessible for the disabled
- Stephen Dubner on the selfish act of altruism











#1 Posted by Cut Spending, May 09, 05:31PM
Or is it?