Hardball Host Chris Matthews (chetlyzarko/flickr)
For the hour of Wednesday's State of the Union address, MSNBC anchor Chris Matthews said he "forgot" President Obama was black, causing a wide range of responses (including some on our show) the next day. Do we all need to forget about race to be post-racial? Or do we just need to acknowledge and accept people's race?
We talk with Boyce Watkins, a professor at Syracuse University and the founder of Your Black World coalition, and Gustavo Arellano, who writes the syndicated "Ask a Mexican" column, about what it means to be post-racial in America.
Today's Takeaway: What the Mortgage Settlement Means
Comedian Baratunde Thurston on 'How to Be Black'
Today's Takeaway: Focus on Violence Syria
In-Depth Look at the Situation in Syria
Some Combat Restrictions for Women Lifted
Today's Takeaway: Big Night for Rick Santorum
'Tebow Bill' May Allow Home-Schoolers to Play on High School Teams
Is Our Constitution Out of Date?
Today's Takeaway: Multi-Billion Dollar Foreclosure Settlement Imminent
David Sanger's Guide to the History of Syria
What the Mortgage Settlement Means for the Housing Market
Notes from the Conservative Political Action Conference
A Closer Look at the Assad Regime
In-Depth Look at the Situation in Syria
Two New Nuclear Reactors Get Go-Ahead
Public Debate Over a Controversial Childhood Obesity Campaign
Follow Friday: CPAC, Gay Marriage, Contraception
Comedian Baratunde Thurston on 'How to Be Black'
What Did Clint and Chrysler Mean by 'Half Time in America'?
Multi-Billion Dollar Foreclosure Settlement Imminent
Contraception Coverage Draws Criticism from Catholic Bishops
No 'Safety Net' for Middle Class?
'Tebow Bill' May Allow Home-Schoolers to Play on High School Teams
Some Combat Restrictions for Women Lifted
Public Debate Over a Controversial Childhood Obesity Campaign
Being Gay: A Listener's Story
US Mayors Take on Gun Control... During the Super Bowl

The show is a co-production of WNYC Radio and Public Radio International, in collaboration with The BBC World Service, New York Times Radio and WGBH Boston.
Major funding provided by:


Comments [7]
First of all, I am tired of the sound-byte mentality of even addressing this issue. What about some gravitas for a change? Obama himself said that everyone was eager to make political points on something someone else said. For starters, the Media made a huge deal about how Obama was our first Black President, as did the President himself. Though he is biracial, he prefers to call himself "Black". So, if we have heard over and over again how glorious it is to have a Black President and if watching his the State of the Union Address we are engaged in his rhetoric, his determination and his wit, rather than having someone trumpet,
"Here comes your Black President", why should anyone take offense at Chris Matthews' comment, unless, of course, it is easier to natter on about that and the reactions to that than to do serious reporting about something of substance:
Educational Successes, Entrepreneurial Success Stories, Medical Miracles, Best Practices Discovered to Avoid Disasters, and Amazing New Art and Artists. Of course bad news pays more, and non-news costs less to report, especially if editors substitute public commentary on "He said, she said" for news reporting.
Obviously Chris has a low expectation for black people. Why else would someone say such a nutty statement
Chris does a good job reporting and has spoken positive numerous times about and on behalf of President Obama. I do not think he should be hammered for his comment. Some other people thought it, but were afraid to say it. It's llike some see a wrong and will speak out while others pretend it did not happen. There are those who will try to make something out of nothing. I watch Chris and think he does an excellent job. Keep up the good work Chris. I am an African American woman.
Chris saying he "forgot" that the president was black, suggests to me that being black is a negative trait, and one that needs to be overlooked. Being black should not be viewed in a negative fashion.
I am a hispanic woman and I am glad that Chris Matthews made this comment. I think that the publics own disbelief about the comment may actually capture our own discomfort regarding this complex issue- is this shocking that we, as humans, make evaluations about someone based on their appearance (including a person's skin color)? Quite honestly, as I watched the State of the Union, I wondered how the "white" audience felt about having a "black" man address them and to what extent does Republican opposition have to do with making sure that our first black president "fails."
Rick beat me to it. It was Democrat Harry Reid who was revealed to have made the skin color comment about Obama in the current bestseller "Game Change." Not Republican Orrin Hatch.
So nice to have this thoughtful conversation about race. Helps that it was liberal commentator and former Democrat Congressional staffer Chris Matthews, on the left-wing MSNBC cable network, who made the utterance. Had anyone said the same thing on the Fox News Channel, there'd be no conversation at all. Only a free-fire zone.
Nobody's perfect. Especially snarky columnists like Gustavo. It was senator Harry Reid and not senator Orrin Hatch who made clumsy comments about "negro dialect". Could Gustavo have been confusing his Mormon senators?
Leave a Comment
Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more. Learn more.
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting. By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.